A bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general challenged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s effort to draw a regulatory line between prediction markets and gambling, arguing that the agency cannot use financial-market rules to override state betting protections.

The attorneys general of 43 states and the District of Columbia submitted two comment letters dated Nov. 18. They asked the CFTC to withdraw a proposal explicitly listing event contracts in its definition of financial instruments called swaps and opposed a companion rule excluding certain licensed gambling products from that category. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport announced the objections Friday.

“These actions seek to override states’ longstanding authority to regulate gambling within our borders,” Davenport said. She said the measures would let prediction markets operate without complying with state gambling rules and responsible-gaming safeguards.

Know when your
coins move

At stake is whether platforms can offer contracts on sports and elections under a single federal framework rather than comply with state-by-state gambling restrictions. Prediction markets let users trade contracts whose payouts depend on future events. The coalition argues that putting a sports bet on an exchange does not make it a financial derivative; industry supporters say the exchange structure is precisely what distinguishes the products.

Two Rules, Different Legal Status

The two measures are not both pending proposals:

  • The CFTC’s ‘Swap’ Inclusions proposal would expressly list event contracts based on sports, politics, culture and weather in the swap definition, codifying the agency’s disputed interpretation of its existing oversight. It has not taken effect.
  • The casino-style gambling exclusion took effect Oct. 19 as an interim final rule. It applies to products regulated as gambling under applicable state or tribal law, offered by a provider acting within its state or qualifying tribal gambling authorization and not traded on an exchange or another specified market. It does not give exchange-traded prediction contracts that exclusion.

Both measures set Nov. 18 as their public-comment deadline.

In their letter opposing the proposed inclusion, the attorneys general argued that sports bets fall outside the statutory meaning of swaps and that Congress did not clearly authorize the CFTC to take over this area of state regulation. The coalition was co-led by Davenport, Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson and the attorneys general of Kentucky, Maryland, Nevada, New York, Tennessee and Utah.

Their second letter attacked the distinction between betting against a gambling operator—the ‘house’—and betting against other participants. States already regulate peer-to-peer wagering and pooled horse-racing bets, they said. The coalition also argued that state laws address compulsive gambling and related household harm, while the Commodity Exchange Act does not, and challenged the CFTC’s rulemaking procedures and statutory authority.

Industry commenters took the opposite position. In a Nov. 18 letter supporting the exclusion, Coinbase argued that regulation should turn on market structure rather than the subject of a contract. It said a state-by-state regime could fracture a national market into smaller pools of trading.

Hyperliquid Policy Center, an independent advocacy organization focused on access to onchain markets, supported the event-contract proposal in a Nov. 16 letter. It asked the CFTC to add an explicit cross-reference to the gambling exclusion, making the boundary between the two measures clear in the rule text.