By Sanqing, Foresight News
At 23:00 on November 19, the U.S. Senate Banking Committee held a hearing on Trump's SEC commissioner nominees Kristin Johnson and Steven Levine. The hearing reviewed five nominees in the same session; the proceedings were brief with little back-and-forth, but the SEC's "innovation exemption" for tokenized stocks, rolled out in September this year, became the core crypto topic the two were asked about.
Earlier, at 4:00 on November 18, the Senate Agriculture Committee had already held a hearing on CFTC commissioner nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland. Lawmakers' questions centered on prediction markets, and Democratic Senator Adam Schiff went so far as to accuse CFTC Chairman Michael Selig on the spot of deceiving him at his 2025 nomination hearing.
The four were submitted to the Senate together by the White House on November 12, two from each party. Johnson and Rowland are also the first Democrats Trump has nominated to these two financial regulators during his second term.
SEC Tokenization Exemption Urged to Go Through Formal Rulemaking
On September 17, 2026, the SEC unveiled the "innovation exemption," allowing eligible tokenized securities trading venues (TSVs) to trade tokenized versions of the shares of U.S.-listed public companies without registering as exchanges. Under this framework, third parties may tokenize a listed company's shares without obtaining its consent, and the company can only object within 30 days of receiving written notice. Since the framework launched, dozens of listed companies have raised objections.
On November 16, Democratic Senators Angela Alsobrooks, Catherine Cortez Masto, Mark Warner and Ruben Gallego sent an open letter to SEC Chairman Paul Atkins, demanding that permanent adjustments to tokenized securities regulation go through the rulemaking process with public comment. At the hearing, Alsobrooks asked the two nominees directly whether they agreed that the policy should be revisited.
Johnson responded that she was willing to push for the issues to be taken up in formal rulemaking with a public comment period, especially since those raising concerns were themselves market participants and registered entities. She also said Congress requires independent federal market regulators to make rules through the public comment process.
Levine said the exemption is time-limited and narrow in scope, citing ETFs to argue that many innovations begin with a series of exemptive orders and ultimately move toward rulemaking.
In her written testimony, Johnson wrote that AI, tokenization, stablecoins and decentralized platforms promise to lower costs and broaden access, but also bring real problems involving conflicts of interest, data governance and accountability; in digital asset markets, she has consistently focused on strong governance, conflict-of-interest rules and segregation of customer assets. Levine's written testimony did not mention crypto assets, saying only that U.S. capital markets are undergoing "transformational innovation."
Cortez Masto also steered the conversation toward prediction markets, alleging that the platforms in question are illegally trading "security-based swaps" in the form of equity-type perpetual contracts, taking direct aim at the CFTC's practice of allowing single-stock perpetual futures. Levine did not comment on this; Johnson said it involves key questions of the committee's jurisdiction and authority.
CFTC Hearing Focuses on Prediction Markets
Under the leadership of Chairman Michael Selig, the CFTC asserts "exclusive jurisdiction" over event contracts, and its proposed rule treats prediction market contracts as swaps subject to federal commodities regulation rather than state gambling laws. States argue that these platforms are illegal gambling operations, while tribes worry about the impact on the gaming compacts they have signed with states. Nearly 12 states and the CFTC are currently suing each other, courts in different jurisdictions have ruled differently, and the cases could ultimately go to the Supreme Court.
At the hearing, Rowland cited Rule 40.11, adopted by the CFTC in 2011, which prohibits registered exchanges from listing or clearing certain event contracts involving gambling, terrorism, war and assassination. He said he "very much understands" the concerns of states and tribes, but found it difficult to comment on ongoing litigation.
Anonick said the CFTC has the authority to determine whether a contract goes against the public interest, that "gambling" is precisely the point of dispute, and described the topic as "very emotional." Democratic Senator Tina Smith pushed back on the spot, arguing that this is a legal question and that jurisdiction over sports betting belongs to states and tribes.
The sharpest remarks at the hearing came from Democratic Senator Adam Schiff. He said that at his November 2025 nomination hearing, Selig described himself as "a blank slate" on the sports event contracts question and said he would follow court rulings, yet afterward filed briefs with the court and urged companies to ignore rulings unfavorable to prediction markets. Schiff said he "doesn't know whether he has ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee."
Asked whether a sports event contract on an NFL game is equivalent to sports betting, neither nominee answered directly, saying only that they would fully support the Supreme Court's final ruling. Rowland expects the Supreme Court may rule on the matter in the next term or the one after that.
Crypto-related content appeared mainly in Rowland's written testimony. He worked as a lawyer at the CFTC for more than 11 years, served as a senior advisor to Johnson, and has also taken part in crypto market structure legislative work. In his testimony he cited FTX as an example, saying that when FTX collapsed, the CFTC-regulated FTX subsidiary did not file for bankruptcy and its customer assets were protected.
He wrote that new markets such as event contracts, crypto derivatives and security futures are growing rapidly, that farmers worry 24/7 trading and perpetual futures will affect hedging markets, and that the CFTC needs to review and strengthen customer protection rules. Anonick's written testimony did not mention crypto assets, saying only that regulation needs to keep pace with the evolution of technology and markets.
A Scramble to Fill Seats During the Lame-Duck Session
Both regulators are currently short of members. Of the SEC's five seats, only Atkins and Mark Uyeda serve as commissioners; if Johnson and Levine are confirmed, that will rise to four, producing a lineup of three Republicans and one Democrat.
The CFTC's situation is more extreme: Selig has operated as the sole commissioner for nearly a year. In her opening remarks, Agriculture Committee Ranking Member Amy Klobuchar said Congress did not design the CFTC to be "an agency governed by one person."
Staff attrition is likewise a prominent issue. A lawmaker noted at the hearing that the CFTC has lost about a quarter of its staff during Selig's tenure, and both nominees said they were willing to add staff as needed. Even if both Anonick and Rowland are confirmed, two CFTC commissioner seats will remain vacant.
The window for confirmation is also tight. Democrats won both the Senate and the House in the November 3 midterm elections, and the new Congress will be sworn in in January 2027, at which point nominations that have not been confirmed generally need to be resubmitted. All four must first pass a vote in their respective committees, then be confirmed by the full Senate.
On the legislative front, the CLARITY Act failed a Senate cloture vote 49 to 50 on September 15; if it cannot be revived during the lame-duck session, it will lapse on January 3, 2027, when the current Congress ends.
As of November 20, neither the Senate Agriculture Committee nor the Banking Committee has announced a vote date for the four nominations.


