Share
Toothpaste and cereal are beating the AI trade, and it isn’t close. Over the past 30 days, the S&P 500 Consumer Staples sector has outperformed S&P 500 Tech by 33%, according to Jonathan Krinsky, chief technical strategist at BTIG.
Krinsky says that is the largest such gap in roughly 25 years. The last time the market favored household goods over silicon this decisively was during the 2000 to 2001 dot-com bust.
The numbers behind the rotation
The split shows up clearly in the sector ETFs. The Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLP) rose 10.9% in October, according to research compiled for this report.
Over the same month, the Technology Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLK) fell 8.3%. That marks the biggest monthly performance swing between the two since early 2001.
The divergence has carried into November. On November 13, XLP gained roughly 1.18% to 1.42%, while XLK slid roughly 1.71% to 2.08%, during a broader market pullback.
The leaders on the defensive side are names your grandparents would recognize. During the recent rotation, Walmart gained 1.1%, Costco rose 1%, and Procter & Gamble added 1.14%.
On the other side of the ledger, Nvidia came under pressure along with wider weakness in semiconductor stocks.
The news moving money, markets, and the world—before your day starts.
Daily. Free. Join 34,000+ readers across crypto, finance, and policy.
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.
Why defensives are suddenly in fashion
The research points to several pressures driving the move. These include skepticism about how much companies are spending on artificial intelligence, surprises in inflation data, and rising yields.
Rising yields matter more for tech than for most sectors. Growth stocks are valued largely on profits expected years from now. When bond yields climb, those distant profits get discounted more heavily, and the stocks tend to get repriced lower.
The dot-com comparison, and its limits
Krinsky’s reference point is a heavy one. The 2000 to 2001 period began with defensive stocks taking the lead as technology shares unwound from bubble-era highs.
Still, many analysts view the current move as a tactical rotation rather than a full regime change, according to the research findings.
Both sectors also remain positive for the year despite the recent gap.
What this means for investors
The most direct implication is for portfolio concentration. Tech has made up a large share of index returns during the AI boom, so many passive investors are more exposed to the sector than they may realize.
Several markers are worth tracking. These include the next rounds of inflation data, the direction of bond yields, and how semiconductor stocks, Nvidia especially, trade from here.
Krinsky’s data does not say a crash is coming. It says the market is behaving the way it did at the start of one of the most painful tech drawdowns in modern history.

