U.S. stablecoin issuers can choose between state and federal supervisory routes if they meet certain requirements, but concerns have been raised that draft rules prepared ahead of the GENIUS Act’s implementation could in effect encourage them to opt for federal approval.

Cointelegraph reported on Nov. 19 that 6 U.S. senators, including Cynthia Lummis and Kirsten Gillibrand, asked U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent in a letter to apply a safe harbour to issuers supervised by state governments as well. A safe harbour is a measure that temporarily defers regulatory application for businesses that meet certain conditions.

The GENIUS Act allows businesses with stablecoins in circulation totalling $10 billion or less to be regulated by state governments under rules that meet federal standards. Even if issuance exceeds that threshold, issuers can keep state supervision if they are granted an exception.

The issue is a gap while the system is being implemented. Under the Treasury’s draft rules, issuers that apply for federal approval can receive safe harbour if they obtain a deferral approval from their relevant regulator. It did not include a comparable measure for issuers seeking state supervision.

The senators said setting up state-by-state regulatory frameworks and verifying qualification would take time, and issuers could choose authorisation from federal regulators such as the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency to avoid uncertainty. They urged that safe harbour should also apply to issuers in states that establish qualifying regulatory frameworks before Jan. 18, 2028. They argued that the legislative intent to allow both federal and state supervision should be reflected in the final rules.

Some also view that expanding safe harbour may not eliminate a preference for federal supervision. Kevin Wisoski (케빈 위소키), policy head at Anchorage Digital, said companies choose federal approval from the outset because they may have to switch supervisors once stablecoin issuance exceeds $10 billion. An exception allows issuers to keep state supervision after crossing the threshold, but it requires separate approval.

Whether the Treasury will create deferral measures for state-supervised issuers remains a key issue. Depending on the final rules, the two supervisory routes guaranteed by the GENIUS Act may or may not become equally viable options in practice.