The U.S. Supreme Court on November 16, 2026, declined to hear Custodia Bank’s appeal in case No. 26-62, leaving intact a 2–1 appellate ruling that regional Federal Reserve Banks may deny master accounts even to legally eligible applicants.

The decision ends Custodia’s bid through this petition to compel direct access to the Federal Reserve’s payment system. The Wyoming bank’s state charter remains insufficient to secure that access, preserving a barrier for crypto-focused institutions seeking to move dollars without a correspondent bank.

Supreme Court Leaves Custodia Bank’s Account Denial in Place

What Happened on November 16?

The Court declined to take up Custodia’s challenge to the Federal Reserve’s refusal to grant it a master account. Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors appeared under “certiorari denied” on the Monday order list.

Related: Rain Pushes Into U.S. Banking With Stablecoin Trust Charter as OCC Faces Legal Challenge

That procedural outcome leaves the lower-court judgment undisturbed. The controlling reasoning in Custodia’s dispute remains the Tenth Circuit’s interpretation of federal banking law, rather than a new Supreme Court opinion on the merits.

Which Decision Survives?

The Tenth Circuit’s October 31, 2025, ruling upheld the Kansas City Fed’s discretion to reject the application. The majority held that meeting the legal requirements to apply does not give a bank an enforceable right to receive an account.

Custodia had asked the Supreme Court to review whether regional Reserve Bank presidents could deny master accounts to legally eligible nonmember banks. Both the Board of Governors and the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City opposed review.

Custodia’s Wyoming Charter Meets Separate Federal Decisions

What Kind of Bank Is Custodia?

Custodia is a Wyoming special purpose depository institution led by chief executive Caitlin Long. Its charter prohibits lending and requires dollar deposits to be fully reserved in liquid assets.

Those requirements underpin the bank’s proposed alternative to conventional banking. Custodia has argued that its model can serve developing industries and provide protection against bank runs, according to earlier reporting on its appeal.

Which Federal Reserve Bodies Rejected Its Requests?

The Kansas City Fed handled the application for a master account, while the Board of Governors handled Custodia’s separate request for Federal Reserve membership. Both applications were rejected on January 27, 2023.

The decisions concerned distinct requests: an account at a regional Reserve Bank and membership in the Federal Reserve System. The Supreme Court petition centered on the authority to deny account access to an otherwise eligible nonmember institution.

The distinction matters to the legal argument. Custodia’s challenge relied on statutory language addressing access for nonmember banks, so the dispute extended beyond whether the Board should approve its membership application.

Custodia’s Application Began in October 2020

How Did an Account Application Become a Lawsuit?

Custodia applied to the Kansas City Fed for a master account in October 2020. The Reserve Bank confirmed its legal eligibility in January 2021, but the application remained pending.

In June 2022, Custodia sued the Board of Governors and the Kansas City Fed over the delay. The case began as an effort to obtain a decision; the subsequent account rejection made the Reserve Bank’s power to refuse access central to the litigation.

How Did the Review Framework Change?

In August 2022, while Custodia’s requests were pending, the Board published guidelines for reviewing master-account applications. Institutions without federal deposit insurance or supervision by a federal banking agency fell into Tier 3.

Custodia was in that category, which the guidelines said would generally receive the strictest review. Its Wyoming charter and legal eligibility therefore left it subject to a demanding federal assessment of its business model.

What Reasons Did the Fed Give for Rejection?

The Kansas City Fed described Custodia’s model as “unprecedented” and “narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities.” It concluded that the associated risks were highly likely to be inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices.

The Board separately said membership approval would be inconsistent with the financial, managerial and corporate powers factors. These were the Fed’s assessments of the applications; Custodia continued to argue for the merits of its banking model.

U.S. District Judge Scott W. Skavdahl ruled against Custodia on March 29, 2024, holding that Reserve Banks have discretion over master accounts and granting the Kansas City Fed summary judgment. The Tenth Circuit later affirmed, and the full appeals court denied rehearing on March 13, 2026.

The Custodia Ruling Turns on “May” and “Shall”

Why Did the Majority Find That Account Access Is Discretionary?

Judge David Ebel, joined by Judge Veronica Rossman, read Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act as granting discretion. The provision says a Reserve Bank “may receive” deposits, language the majority treated as permission to accept them rather than an obligation.

The bank’s competing argument relied on the Monetary Control Act of 1980, which says Federal Reserve services “shall be available” to nonmember banks. The majority interpreted that requirement as a pricing rule rather than an entitlement to a master account.

That interpretation separates eligibility from approval. An institution can qualify to seek Federal Reserve services while a regional Reserve Bank retains authority to reject the account needed for direct access.

Why Did the Dissent Disagree?

Judge Timothy Tymkovich read the 1980 law as requiring access to Federal Reserve payment services for all nonmember depository institutions. He rejected the majority’s narrower interpretation of its mandatory wording.

“We are bound by the ordinary language of the statute and, in my view, shall means shall,” he wrote in dissent. His position would have given the availability requirement a different practical consequence for eligible applicants such as Custodia.

The disagreement was about the obligation imposed by federal law. The majority’s reading prevailed, allowing the Kansas City Fed’s refusal to stand despite Custodia’s statutory eligibility.

A 2–1 Split Leaves Limited Recourse for Rejected Applicants

What Does the Appellate Division Mean for Custodia?

Ebel and Rossman formed the appellate majority, with Tymkovich dissenting. The 2–1 division belongs to the Tenth Circuit’s decision on account access.

Custodia pursued further review after losing that appeal, first seeking rehearing and then petitioning the Supreme Court in July 2026. The November refusal leaves the outcome reached by the appellate majority in place.

The effort stretches from an application submitted in 2020 to a Supreme Court order issued in 2026. The lawsuit itself began in 2022, after Custodia had already waited for the Kansas City Fed to act.

How Far Does the Surviving Ruling Reach?

The practical consequence is particularly significant within the Tenth Circuit. As Bitcoin Magazine described the outcome, rejected crypto-focused banks and other novel charters have limited judicial recourse there when a Reserve Bank refuses access.

The surviving judgment is an appellate precedent. The Supreme Court’s refusal to review it leaves that judgment intact, without issuing a merits opinion adopting the majority’s statutory reasoning.

For another state-chartered applicant, the distinction between eligibility and entitlement remains crucial. Obtaining a charter can establish a basis to apply while leaving the federal account decision unresolved.

Custodia’s Dispute Preserves a Banking-Access Barrier

What Changes for Direct Payment Access?

A master account would give Custodia direct access to Fedwire and other Federal Reserve payment services. Without one, a state-chartered bank must use a correspondent institution to move money.

Custodia argued that dependence on intermediaries limited the competitiveness of digital-asset banks despite their state regulation. Its application sought to remove that dependence by placing the bank directly within the Federal Reserve’s payment network.

The account denial preserves that obstacle. For crypto-focused banking businesses, the consequence concerns their route into dollar payments and the institutions on which they must rely.

Where Do the Bank’s Position and the Fed’s Concerns Diverge?

Custodia emphasized a charter that bars lending and requires liquid assets against dollar deposits. The Kansas City Fed focused on the risks it associated with a business concentrated on crypto-asset activities.

The court dispute put the authority to make the account decision at issue. Under the surviving interpretation, the Reserve Bank could exercise that authority even after acknowledging that Custodia was legally eligible.

That leaves a significant hurdle for institutions built under specialized state charters. Their proposed safeguards must pass the federal review process before they can secure the direct payment access Custodia sought.

Correspondent Banking Remains the Alternative to Direct Access

What Is the Immediate Result for Custodia?

The existing master-account denial stands, and the Supreme Court review sought through this petition has ended. Custodia has not obtained the court order it pursued to compel the Kansas City Fed to grant an account.

Correspondent banking remains the alternative identified for a state-chartered institution without its own master account. That route retains an intermediary between the institution and the Federal Reserve’s payment services.

What Other Payment-Account Model Is Under Development?

The Defiant says the Fed is developing a narrower payment-account model. That work provides another banking-access development to watch as the current master-account framework remains in place.

For Custodia’s case, the immediate outcome follows the existing framework: regional Reserve Banks retain discretion under the surviving Tenth Circuit ruling, and the bank’s requested direct access remains denied.

FAQ

Who Represented Custodia in Its Supreme Court Petition?

Kannon Shanmugam filed Custodia’s July 2026 petition. It asked the Court to review whether regional Reserve Bank presidents could refuse master accounts to legally eligible nonmember banks.

What Did the Kansas City Fed Initially Tell Custodia?

In January 2021, the Kansas City Fed confirmed Custodia’s legal eligibility and said there were “no showstoppers.” That early response preceded the stricter review framework published in August 2022 and the eventual rejection.

When Did Custodia Apply for Federal Reserve Membership?

Custodia submitted its membership application in August 2021. It was a separate request to the Board of Governors, following the master-account application made to the Kansas City Fed.

What Happened to Custodia’s Administrative Procedure Act Claim?

The district court dismissed that claim for lack of a final agency action on March 29, 2024. In the same ruling, Judge Skavdahl granted summary judgment to the Kansas City Fed on the account-access dispute.

Which Judges Supported Rehearing the Appeal?

Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid voted to grant rehearing in March 2026. The full Tenth Circuit nevertheless denied the request, leaving Custodia to pursue Supreme Court review.

Why Did a Judge Call Account Denial “Akin to a Death Sentence”?

Tymkovich used that phrase in his dissent from the March 2026 rehearing denial to emphasize the importance of master-account access. It was his assessment of the consequences of exclusion from those services.

When Did the Supreme Court Consider Custodia’s Petition?

The case was distributed for the Court’s November 13, 2026, conference. The refusal to review it appeared on the November 16 order list.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice.

AI Trading Firm Drops Deal for Trump-Linked Crypto Business

Fintech company Perpetuals has walked away from buying an Alt5 payments business, just seven days...

Asia Surges Into the AI Race — China and Japan Launch New Models Amid US Anthropic Restrictions

US export restrictions, particularly targeting Anthropic, have ignited a new phase of the AI race....

Russia’s Crypto Market Shake-Up: Sberbank Wins Approval Ahead of December 1 Launch

Russia’s leading bank, Sberbank, has received approval from the Bank of Russia to provide...

Charles Schwab Launches Direct Bitcoin and Ethereum Trading

The rollout is happening in phases, but some retail clients already have access. Brokerage giant...

Trump’s Crypto Bank Is Coming: World Liberty Gets Conditional OCC Approval for USD1

Donald Trump’s family-backed World Liberty Financial has moved one step closer to opening...

Bitcoin ATM Operator CoinFlip Sued by Missouri Over Scam Claims

Bitcoin ATM operator CoinFlip was sued by Missouri’s attorney general over claims it enabled...