November 19, 2026

By Phillip Basil - Director of Economic Growth and Financial Stability Benjamin Schiffrin - Director of Securities Policy

The states have a strong interest in protecting the health and welfare of their citizens, and have served as an important source of protection for American consumers over the years. The federal government often shares that interest in consumer protection, but under the Trump administration, deregulation has become the norm. And now, federal financial agencies are not only wiping federal protections off the books but are insisting that federal rules supersede state protections whenever a federal law arguably applies—a very aggressive application of the concept known as preemption. In doing so, these federal agencies are completely overriding the will of the states that seek to protect their citizens from harm, and, often, are acting contrary to the same federal laws they claim to be administering.  

Clearly, the administration is doing this to benefit large and influential financial institutions like big banks, investment funds, the crypto industry, and betting “prediction” markets, at the expense of hardworking American people who are being exploited. Due to the federal agencies’ preemption agenda, these institutions are able to sidestep basic state-level consumer protections.  

The inevitable consequence of this unchecked federal power is consumers, retail investors, and businesses being ripped off by financial institutions and increased financial instability. The states, as well as consumers, investors, and small businesses, are standing up to the efforts of the federal financial agencies in court, and the fight against unchecked federal power must continue for the benefit of all Americans.  

The banking agencies are coordinating to preempt state laws 

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) is the federal banking agency that has the authority to grant federal bank charters, which provide financial institutions with the legal authorization to operate as a bank. States also have authorities that issue bank charters, but a federal charter allows banks to ignore nearly all state laws and rules where federal preemption applies. However, the issue of where and how federal preemption of state laws applies for banks has been an ongoing battle in the legal system and, as highlighted above, has led to the severe consequences of the Financial Crisis.  

Nonetheless, earlier this year the OCC ignored this battle and used its rulemaking authority to assert—without basis—federal preemption on a very specific and seemingly non-material issue. The issue was regarding state laws that require banks to pay interest to mortgage borrowers on their money that sits in escrow accounts used to pay taxes and homeowners insurance. The OCC asserted that federally chartered banks don’t have to pay that interest if they don’t want to, regardless of what state laws say. The OCC’s intention was clear: the preemption assertion on that issue was a signal that federal preemption for banks applies absolutely in all cases.  

However, the OCC’s assertion was baseless and ignored existing laws and legal precedent. State interest-on-escrow laws have existed for decades, and the OCC failed to provide any explanation as to why was changing its position after so many years. Additionally, there is clear language in the law showing Congress’s view that such state laws should not fall under federal preemption. Furthermore, the OCC blatantly ignored existing legal decisions, including a Supreme Court decision that rejected the OCC’s previous 2004 rule that also attempted to assert federal preemption. 

Subsequently, the OCC issued a rule that asserted preemption over a more material Illinios law that exempts taxes and tips from the interchange fees banks charge on card transactions. This assertion similarly lacked the support of existing laws and legal precedent. 

The OCC’s motivation is transparently industry-focused. OCC federal preemption would benefit the country’s biggest banks as well as the crypto industry. While OCC-chartered banks are only 21 percent of banks by number (880 banks out of over 4,200), they hold nearly 70 percent of total bank assets. Those banks, especially the very largest bank—like JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. with over $4 trillion in assets and Bank of America, N.A. with $2.7 trillion in assets—can boost their profits and streamline their operations if they can completely ignore state laws. Similarly, a big issue in the crypto industry has been the need to comply with the laws and rules of all 50 states, each of which can have its own framework. However, the OCC has granted bank charters to numerous crypto companies, which will create huge efficiencies and profit boosts for them and allow them to compete directly with real banks.  

States Attorneys General and private interest groups are pushing back on the OCC’s federal preemption assertions. The attorneys general of California, Connecticut, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, and Vermont are challenging the OCC’s interest-on-escrow rules, as is the Independent Community Bankers of America. Similarly, the Attorney General of Illinois is challenging the OCC’s rule preempting that state’s law on interchange fees. 

More recently, the FDIC issued a proposal that would extend the concept of federal preemption to banks with state-issued bank charters for their operations in other states. The FDIC is doing this under the pretext that state-chartered banks should not be at a disadvantage to national banks, but that disadvantage would not exist in the first place had the OCC not baselessly asserted federal preemption for banks with its charters. 

The SEC is blatantly ignoring Congressional intent  

Federal overreach isn’t just limited to banking law. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is ignoring Congress’s intent when it comes to federal preemption of state securities laws. Section 18 of the Securities Act of 1933 says that, when securities are sold to the public, federal law preempts state law registration and qualification requirements with respect to securities offered and sold to “qualified purchasers” as defined by the Commission.  This is supposed to be a meaningful limit that ensures retail investors receive the protection of state securities laws. 

Nonetheless, in a number of recent proposals, the SEC would define a qualified purchaser as any person or entity to whom securities are offered or sold, including retail investors. This definition, which would render the qualified purchaser limitation meaningless by including all purchasers as qualified purchasers, nullifies Congress’s intent. The legislative history indicates that Congress believed that any definition of qualified purchaser “should ‘be rooted in the belief that “qualified” purchasers are sophisticated investors, capable of protecting themselves in a manner that renders regulation by State authorities unnecessary.’” Yet the Commission proposes to define a qualified purchaser as including retail investors—the very investors who, as Congress recognized, need the protections that state registration and qualification requirements provide. 

Not only does the SEC ignore the legislative history demonstrating Congress’s intent, but it also ignores its own previous recognition of this legislative history. In 2001, the Commission proposed to define a “qualified purchaser” as an “accredited investor.” In so doing, it said that the “legislative history indicates that qualified purchasers” should be limited to investors who “do not require the protections of” state securities laws due to “their financial sophistication and ability to fend for themselves.”  The SEC does not explain why it now ignores this limitation in its proposals. 

Indeed, the SEC actually says in one of its proposals that preempting state laws with respect to securities offered to all individuals is “consistent with the legislative intent underlying the preemption provisions in section 18.” It is not, and it is inexplicable that the SEC would say it is.    

Similarly inexplicable is the SEC’s discussion of preemption in its proposed Regulation Crypto Assets. The SEC recognizes that Securities Act Section 18 allows it to define the term “qualified purchaser” differently with respect to different categories of securities, so long as doing so is “consistent with the public interest and the protection of investors.” Yet the SEC does not explain how defining a qualified purchaser as all purchasers of crypto offerings, which would deprive retail investors of state law protections for such offerings, is in the public interest and protects investors. 

That is because it cannot do so. The risky nature of crypto assets, which involve securities offerings that are rampant with fraud and abuse, makes it all the more important that state laws apply to crypto offerings. Far from being consistent with investor protection, the SEC’s desire to preempt state law protections with respect to crypto offerings would “substantially weaken state regulators’ ability to stop fraudulent and abusive crypto offerings before the damage is done, leaving them largely to pursue bad actors after investors have already lost their money.”  

The CFTC is also ignoring Congressional intent 

The CFTC is similarly ignoring Congress’s intent with respect to so-called event contracts on sporting events. These event contracts, which are offered on prediction markets rather than sportsbooks, are nothing more than gambling products. Yet the CFTC says that the Commodity Exchange Act, which concerns financial derivatives, preempts state and tribal gambling laws. 

That is because the CFTC says event contracts on sporting events constitute a financial instrument known as a swap, which the CFTC has the exclusive jurisdiction to regulate under the Commodity Exchange Act. This would prevent states and tribes from enforcing their rules and regulations regarding sports betting against the prediction markets. The problem for the CFTC is that event contracts on sporting events are not swaps—a fact that Congress has long recognized. 

In 2010, Congress passed a rule that authorized the CFTC to ban event contracts that involve gaming or activity that is unlawful under any state law. The purpose of this rule was to ensure that the CFTC would not allow bad actors to try to pass off event contracts that involve gaming as swaps or other legitimate financial derivatives. So, far from preempting state and tribal gambling laws, Congress wanted them to retain their authority to regulate products that involved gambling. 

A colloquy between two Senators back in 2010 makes this crystal clear. Discussing the rule, Senator Blanche Lincoln said that its purpose was to “prevent gambling through futures markets.” Senator Dianne Feinstein asked whether the intent was to prevent event contracts that would be used predominantly by speculators rather than for a commercial or hedging use, which is the purpose of legitimate financial derivatives. Senator Lincoln answered that that was the rule’s intent. 

Senator Lincoln explained the reason it was important to limit the types of event contracts that fall under the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. She said the idea was not to “enable gambling through supposed ‘event contracts.’” According to Senator Lincoln, it “would be quite easy to construct an ‘event contract’ around sporting events such as the Super Bowl, the Kentucky Derby, and the Masters Golf Tournament.” But those contracts “would not serve any real commercial purpose” and would instead “be used solely for gambling.” So Congress did not want gambling products to escape the rules that govern gambling under the guise that they were financial derivatives. 

Prediction markets want to avoid the state and tribal laws that have traditionally governed gambling. This is why the CFTC—the prediction markets’ chief cheerleader—says its authority to regulate swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act preempts states’ and tribes’ ability to regulate event contracts on sporting events. But the consequences of accepting this argument and allowing prediction markets to evade state and tribal gambling restrictions would be disastrous.  

Even the CFTC admits that, from the perspective of the public, betting on a sportsbook and betting on an event contract on a prediction market look the same. Yet sportsbooks subject to state and tribal gambling laws have addiction resources such as self-exclusions, which prevent problem gamblers from using their sites. Prediction markets that evade these laws are able to lure in problem gamblers even after they have tried to ensure that they can’t access gambling platforms. 

The ability of prediction markets to evade state and tribal gambling laws also means they can offer their event contracts to 18-year-olds. Most sportsbooks require their users to be over 21. This means prediction markets can lure in high school students, and because they say event contracts on sporting events involving trading financial derivatives, it means they can portray their platforms to high school students as involving investing and learning about finance rather than gambling.    

There are also states that do not allow sports betting because they want to protect their residents from the perceived harms that sports betting entails. These states believe sports betting is a public nuisance that harms their residents. By claiming that the Commodity Exchange Act preempts the ability of these states to regulate event contracts on sporting events, the CFTC is aiding and abetting prediction markets in circumventing the ability of these states to protect their citizens.  

Conclusion   

Federal authority is not absolute. Both Congress and the courts have made it clear that certain state laws and rules should not be preempted by federal rules. That’s because Congress and the courts recognize that the design of our framework was to allow states to protect their citizens and businesses in the way they see fit.  

The assertion of total and absolute preemption by the federal financial agencies reflects the interests of large and influential financial institutions that would prefer to ignore state laws with which they don’t agree or care to follow. This is unfair to American households and small businesses that are left unprotected by their state’s laws and rules. The agencies must reverse course from unchecked federal power before they cause significant harm to Main Street Americans.