Dek: A federal judge sent Letitia James' lawsuit back to Manhattan Supreme Court. Hours later, Kalshi asked the state judge not to issue an emergency order before it could respond, warning that the order New York wants could shut down its exchange nationwide.
Kalshi's fight with New York is back in the court where it started, and the company is trying to stop a shutdown order before the state can ask for one again.
U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick on Thursday granted Attorney General Letitia James' motion to remand her enforcement lawsuit to New York County Supreme Court. He rejected Kalshi's arguments that the case belongs in federal court and ordered the clerk to "effect immediate remand."
That night, Kalshi's lawyers at Milbank filed a letter asking Justice Melissa Crane to require notice and briefing before ruling on any renewed request for a temporary restraining order (TRO), according to DeFi Rate's litigation tracker. The company argued that the order James originally proposed would reach far beyond sports contracts for New York customers and could shut down the entire exchange, which is based in New York.
Why Broderick sent the case back
James filed the lawsuit July 31 under New York Executive Law Section 63(12), which lets the attorney general seek to stop repeated illegal business conduct. The petition brings eight causes of action under the state constitution, state penal and racing laws, and the federal Wire Act. Kalshi moved the case to federal court the same day.
Kalshi based the removal on the federal officer removal statute, which lets people acting under federal authority move some cases to federal court. It pointed to its status as a designated contract market regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Broderick found that the Commodity Exchange Act matters to the case only as Kalshi's defense, not as a basis for federal jurisdiction. He also noted that the CFTC had not sought to intervene.
He found that only the Wire Act claim raises a federal issue, and that the issue is not substantial. He also said the balance between state and federal courts gave him an independent reason to send the case back.
"The scope of laws regulating gambling and lotteries is clearly a matter of predominantly state concern," Broderick wrote, quoting an earlier decision.
Kalshi did not lose everything. Broderick denied New York's request for attorneys' fees, writing that he "cannot conclude Kalshi lacked an objectively reasonable basis for seeking removal."
Because he no longer had jurisdiction, he also did not rule on Kalshi's request for a protective order against the attorney general's investigative subpoena.
The emergency order is the immediate fight
The next step depends on a TRO request that has been on hold since August.
After Kalshi removed the case, Crane marked it disposed on Aug. 3. She denied James' injunction motion as moot and said the state could file again if the case came back. The case is now back, so James can renew that request.
The order James first proposed would bar Kalshi from offering contracts on "sports, culture, elections, and other events" made "within or from New York or to persons in New York.”
The words "from New York" are at the center of Kalshi's argument. Because the company is headquartered in New York, Milbank argues the order could stop it from serving customers in every state, not just New Yorkers. Kalshi also questioned whether "other events" could cover contracts on financial markets and economic data. The company warned the order could force it to unwind open positions and disrupt markets in states where its contracts are allowed.
To show the stakes, the letter cited Kalshi's $178 billion in annual trading volume and its $22 billion valuation. Kalshi says both figures come from the attorney general's own filings.
Kalshi also argued there is no emergency that would justify an ex parte order, meaning one issued before Kalshi can respond. It said it has operated since July 2021 and has offered sports contracts since January 2025, more than a year before James sued.
The New York State Gaming Commission sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter on Oct. 24, 2025, then agreed to hold off on enforcement while Kalshi sought a preliminary injunction in federal court.
Kalshi said it contacted the attorney general's office Thursday evening about next steps. The state said it would respond the next day, and Kalshi filed its letter anyway. No hearing date has been set.
The CFTC's emergency order could create a conflict
Kalshi's letter also points to a federal order that could clash with any state shutdown.
As DeFi Rate reported, the CFTC used its emergency powers on Aug. 11. It called New York's lawsuit and TRO request a "major market disturbance" and ordered Kalshi to keep operating its exchange under normal practices and the agency's core principles.
Milbank argues that a state TRO would put Kalshi under conflicting state and federal orders, and that the issue should be fully briefed before any emergency restrictions take effect.
What New York wants
James alleges Kalshi runs an unlicensed sports betting business in New York. She says it lets customers as young as 18 trade, even though New York's minimum age for mobile sports betting is 21, and that it offers bets on games involving New York college teams, which state law prohibits.
The state wants Kalshi to give up its alleged illegal gains, pay restitution to consumers and pay fines equal to three times those gains. A filing with the lawsuit estimated the total at $36 billion. ESPN described that as a minimum estimate pending a full accounting, which includes $100,000 for each attempt to offer unlicensed sports wagering.
Four New York cases, four timelines
James' lawsuit is one of several New York cases against Kalshi, and each moves on its own schedule.
The first is Kalshi's own federal challenge against the NYSGC. As DeFi Rate reported, U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi a preliminary injunction on July 7. She ruled that New York gambling law can apply to its sports contracts even if they are federally regulated swaps.
On Nov. 3, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals denied Kalshi an injunction pending appeal, and the appeal is still pending. Among the parties that have filed briefs supporting New YOrk include
Thirty-seven states, D.C., the Northern Mariana Islands
American Gaming Association
Former CFTC Chair Gary Gensler
Gaming regulator associations
As DeFi Rate reported, the NYSGC has asked a Manhattan court to enforce its July 31 subpoenas. Those subpoenas seek records on sports contracts, users under 21, advertising and Kalshi's corporate structure. A hearing is set for Dec. 14. James' office separately asked a state court to compel information about Kalshi's "potential false or deceptive advertising.”
Last is the federal government's own case. The United States and CFTC sued New York in the Southern District of New York, and their preliminary injunction motion is still pending before Judge Lorna Schofield after argument in September.
Under New York precedent, Kalshi's executives could be held personally liable, and because the company is based in New York, it could be ordered to repay customers nationwide.
James has also sued Polymarket US. That case was removed to federal court, where Judge Ronnie Abrams asked the parties whether it should be paused until the Second Circuit rules.
New York's case is part of a national fight
The remand comes as states win more fights over which court hears these cases.
Louisiana has asked to send its prediction market case back to state court, and Polymarket opposes that request. The CFTC sued Louisiana after a state judge issued a broad restraining order there.
The appeals courts are still split. The Third Circuit ruled for Kalshi in New Jersey. The Ninth Circuit in Nevada, the Sixth Circuit in Ohio and Tennessee, and a divided Fourth Circuit in Maryland have ruled against it.
Kalshi's response to New Jersey's Supreme Court petition is due Dec. 7.
New York could matter more than most of these cases because Kalshi is based there.



