New research found that most broad option income ETFs don’t outperform their benchmarks. Whether that’s concerning depends on the fund.

Sign up for exclusive news and analysis of the rapidly evolving ETF landscape.

Lilly Riddle

Distributions are income-generating ETFs’ lifeblood, but a new report found that some funds have a higher hematocrit than others.

More than two-thirds of broad option income products failed to meet their reported benchmarks, according to a recent report from the ETF research site ETFIQ. This means that, year to date, the funds’ investors ended up with less cash than the products’ benchmarks would have given them. Still, the spread was large, with both distributions and their sources varying from issuer to issuer; some distributions were funded by the product’s income, while others simply gave back investors’ own capital. The difference points to how important it is for advisors to know what they’re buying in advance, said Adam Patti, founder of ETFIQ and CEO of VistaShares.

“A lot of investors may see the headline distribution number and say, ‘Wow, I’m going to get that.’ But you have to look at the underlying asset,” Patti said. “If it’s a semiconductor product, or an Nvidia single-stock product, your volatility is going to be much more enhanced versus an S&P 500 product. You really have to start there and do your analysis.”

Benchmarks the Spot

When it comes to options-based funds, no two are alike. Some write calls while others buy puts; some use an S&P 500 benchmark, others use Treasury bills or bitcoin. This makes it difficult to say whether a fund that “misses the mark” is really at fault, said Cinthia Murphy, director of research at TMX VettaFi. There is also a disconnect between promised returns and distributions that could stem from tax-loss harvesting: “Is this a return-of-capital exercise in order to match yields in a situation where your underlying [holding] may be posting losses, or is this a tax harvesting exercise where you’re deliberately trying to be as tax efficient as you can to meet those yields?” Murphy said.

For example, while roughly half of Direxion’s median funds drew their cash payouts from “return of capital” — that is, investors’ own money — 100% of YieldMax’s median fund did so. “Brands like YieldMax offer crazy high payouts,” Murphy said. “There’s been increasing scrutiny into how these funds actually meet these distribution levels.”

The report also found:

  • The higher a fund’s distribution rate, the worse the price, and the further behind the benchmark the ETF fell.
  • The median fund with a distribution rate of 8% saw a price change of -0.2% compared to -41% for a fund with a rate of between 30% and 60%.

Vigilant Diligence: The question for investors is whether an ETF is structurally sound, Murphy said. If a fund is liquidating assets just to sustain a high payout rate, it likely isn’t a sound investment. But if it’s using tax-loss harvesting or derivative accounting rules, it could be capturing true economic returns. “Each [fund] is employing a different type of strategy, a different type of option strategy, a different type of underlying holding strategy and completely different payout levels,” she said. “Unfortunately, there is no shortcut for due diligence here.”

Exclusive news and analysis of the rapidly evolving ETF landscape, built for advisors and capital allocators.

Recent News

What the Nvidia Debacle Means for ETFs

AI was already having a rough moment. Nvidia’s not making it any better.

Midterm Results Trigger Record Nasdaq Sell-off, Rattling Chip and AI Funds

Tech ETFs took the brunt of the Nasdaq’s $2.5 trillion drop, as record trading volume in QQQ and SOXL signals fear over the future of AI spending.

Defiance Goes Mad ‘Maxx’ on Single-Stock ETFs

The issuer is prepping more than 50 long-dated call-option ETFs, largely single-stock funds tied to tech and AI companies.

Franklin Templeton’s New ETFs Drip-Feed Investors Bitcoin

The two funds, which begin with a 95/5 split between equities and bitcoin, automatically reinvest dividends in crypto.

State Street Rolls Out 401(k)-Friendly Share Class of SPYM

The company, which has ambitions to expand the reach of its ETF strategies into defined contribution plans, is among the first to add a mutual-fund share class of an ETF.

Tokenization Is Growing, But Still Not Grown Up

Janus Henderson just launched a tokenized Nasdaq fund, but a fully tokenized, issuer-sponsored US ETF has yet to hit the market.

Exclusive: USCF May Be Up for Grabs After Marygold Sale

Simplify Asset Management, which has made multiple bids for Marygold, said it was approached by Marygold’s incoming CEO about a potential deal for USCF Investments after the larger entity is acquired by Madison Dearborn.

Not Everything Needs to Be an ETF, Invesco’s Brian Hartigan says 

The issuer, with nearly $1 trillion in ETF assets, recently launched the Invesco Nasdaq International Innovators 100 ETF (QQI) and has plans for more.

With Hester Peirce’s SEC Exit, Crypto Industry Loses an Ally

The commissioner pushed for a less heavy-handed approach to regulation.

BlackRock Makes a Splash with Dual Share Classes

The massive asset manager is the latest to add ETF share classes to its existing mutual funds, giving the treatment to $55 billion of products.

Northern Trust Initiates Record-Breaking Mutual-Fund-to-ETF Conversion

The company will convert six mutual funds with collective assets of $33 billion.

For Sale: What Asset Managers Want in Indie ETF Shops

There are a number of things to consider, including the fate of the products investors love, when their issuer is acquired.