Castle Island Ventures Partner Nic Carter has criticized the business models of most Bitcoin treasury companies, arguing that they offer limited benefits beyond the Bitcoin exposure investors can already obtain through exchange-traded funds (ETFs). His comments highlight growing pressure on digital asset treasury firms to develop distinct strategies and deliver additional shareholder value.

Table of Contents

Carter voiced his opinion in an interview held by Natalie Brunell on October 27, 2026. According to him, investors interested in obtaining exposure to Bitcoin via the securities route can achieve this simply by investing in a spot Bitcoin ETF. The products give direct exposure to Bitcoin without having to invest in a firm that holds Bitcoin in its treasury.

Also Read | Solana Tablet Test Sparks Fresh Debate Over Validator Hardware: Report

Bitcoin ETFs Increase Competition for Treasury Companies

The firms that hold the digital assets in treasuries are also called DATs. They acquire funds via stock issuances, borrowings, and other financing methods, and then use them to invest in Bitcoin. The shares of these companies make it possible for investors to indirectly own cryptocurrencies through the stock exchange.

However, Carter thinks that there is very little innovation on the side of Bitcoin treasury companies. While admitting that some firms came up with interesting models, Carter argues that the overwhelming majority of them have nothing special in contrast to other investment instruments.

Stacks Bitcoin Bond Attracts Institutional Participation

Some of the companies using Bitcoins have been seeking ways of earning more money through their Bitcoins. In an interview mentioned on The Wolf Of All Streets, Stacks co-founder Muneeb Ali revealed that Bullish and others had subscribed to the company’s third Bitcoin bond with a capacity of 1,000 BTC.

According to Ali, the product makes it possible for the institutions to earn yield in the form of Bitcoins directly on the balance sheet. Ali also confirmed that Stacks adds more capacity each month, adding that the third Bitcoin bond is the largest that has been offered so far. It shows the efforts that are being made by companies to make money other than capital gains.

However, the Stacks co-founder added that the participating institutions should have some STX tokens in order to use the product. Ali referred to STX as an access asset and likened participating in the product to having limited tickets for attending a certain event.

Bitcoin Treasury Corporation Shows Different Approach

Bitcoin Treasury Corporation is one of the companies that can use methods of creating value for its shareholders apart from just acquiring Bitcoins. As revealed in its announcement made on November 4, 2026, the Canadian firm bought and cancelled 99,500 common shares in the month of October.

It achieved this at an average cost of $3.91 per share. Additionally, it disclosed that the Bitcoin Per Share (BPS) had risen by 1.42% year-to-date to 0.00006435 BTC. These statistics reveal how share buybacks could influence the quantity of Bitcoin held in each diluted share.

On October 31, Bitcoin Treasury Corporation was holding 732.47 BTC, whereas the share dilution of the firm was recorded at 11,383,313. The firm indicated that its total holdings of Bitcoin had gone down during the year notwithstanding the rise in BPS. This explains the reason why one needs to look into the reserve and share figures.

Another point to note is that the Bitcoin lending operations and Bitcoin Price Risk Management Program of the company were considered part of its operating strategy. It is expected that revenues generated through these programs would fund future repurchase of shares. This represents an instance where a treasury company creates financial services using its Bitcoin reserves.

Treasury Companies Face Pressure to Prove Value

Carter’s critique emerges as the investor focus turns more towards comparing the approach of corporates in dealing with Bitcoin with the existing alternative investment vehicles. It becomes important for the Treasury companies to prove why their stocks should be considered in light of the fact that there are ETFs available for Bitcoin investments.

One of the things that would matter in the future of the industry would be the sustainability of operations based on crypto reserves held by companies. There can be new opportunities for business including Bitcoin lending, financial services, and capital management. At the same time, these would bring new challenges for investors.

Thus, Carter’s comments reveal a change in the market’s approach towards Bitcoin treasury companies. Bitcoin holding might not suffice for keeping investors interested in light of the presence of easier alternatives such as ETFs. The companies that would succeed in establishing their operations and managing capital and providing high shareholder value would get more chances to distinguish themselves in the market.

Also Read | Injective Expands US and European Market Access as INJ Price Outlook Improves

Bena Ilyas

Bena Ilyas is a Global News Correspondent and Market Analyst at Tronweekly with over four years of experience covering global cryptocurrency, blockchain, and Web3 developments. She has written 1,000+ articles for leading crypto news platforms, reporting on Bitcoin, Ethereum, altcoins, DeFi, and global crypto regulation, alongside Web3 trends, Layer 2 ecosystems, and AI-driven crypto use cases. Her work is based on verified sources and fact-based reporting for global market participants.