Four Democratic senators are demanding that the Securities and Exchange Commission explain how tokenized shares are prevented from flowing into unverified or offshore wallets, arguing that the agency's five-year exemption for on-chain equity trading leaves a hole in the U.S. anti-money laundering perimeter.

Sens. Angela Alsobrooks of Maryland, Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada, Mark Warner of Virginia and Ruben Gallego of Arizona sent a 13-question letter to SEC Chair Paul Atkins dated Nov. 16, seeking answers within 30 days. The lawmakers contend that the Innovation Exemption, issued Sept. 17, requires tokenized securities venues to be U.S. persons subject to OFAC sanctions screening but imposes no identity-verification standard and no mandatory anti-money laundering program.

"As a result, a tokenized equity purchased by a verified individual could be transferred to an unverified wallet, including one held by a foreign person or illicit actor, beyond the reach of the U.S. regulatory perimeter," the letter states.

The senators also argued that the order does not classify tokenized securities venues as financial institutions under the Bank Secrecy Act, the statute that obliges banks and brokers to verify customers and report suspicious transactions. Once a token sits in an outside wallet, they said, the exemption does not clearly establish which AML requirements apply.

The letter zeroes in on the permissioned automated market makers and liquidity pools the relief permits. Qualifying venues can trade tokenized National Market System stocks -- ordinary listed U.S. equities -- on-chain without registering as securities exchanges, and certain liquidity providers receive relief from the dealer definition. That relief runs through Sept. 17, 2031. The SEC acted under existing authority after the Senate failed to advance the Digital Asset Market CLARITY Act.

The lawmakers wrote that "a tokenized security is a security" and said they are "concerned the Exemption lacks clarity in three crucial areas." Trading access is permissioned at the point of purchase, they noted, but the underlying smart contracts carry no transfer restrictions.

Beyond illicit finance, the letter raises questions about issuer consent and retail safeguards. More than 60 public companies have objected to having their shares tokenized, yet the exemption gives issuers only a 30-day window to object after a venue notifies them, with no mechanism for a standing objection, a later objection or withdrawal of consent once given. The senators also said retail investors can buy tokenized equities directly from a venue without a broker-dealer, while the exemption leaves unclear which protections apply, including advertising rules, best-execution duties and SIPC insurance. Venues are not required to comply with Regulation NMS, meaning they need not display their best prices or report trades in real time.

The letter asks Atkins to detail how the SEC will enforce AML compliance, verify venues' self-disclosures and track or recover tokens that move to unverified wallets. It also requests that any future changes to the exemption go through formal rulemaking rather than take effect immediately, as the September order did.

The SEC declined to comment. Atkins said when the exemption was announced that federal anti-fraud and anti-manipulation rules would continue to apply in full.

The scrutiny lands seven days before OKXICE, a venture between crypto exchange OKX and Intercontinental Exchange, the parent of the New York Stock Exchange, plans to begin tokenized stock trading for eligible U.S. customers outside traditional market hours on Nov. 23. Its Nov. 5 public notice listed 67 companies that objected to their shares being tokenized, including Tesla and Nvidia; issuers who object within a 30-day window cannot be listed under the exemption. The senators' letter puts the objector count at more than 60.

Note: The exemption's relief period and the OKXICE launch date come from the SEC order and the venue's public notice, respectively.

The dispute matters for the pace at which Wall Street instruments migrate on-chain. The exemption is the legal foundation for venues that want to list tokenized versions of U.S. equities without exchange registration, and a finding that transfer controls are inadequate could force the SEC to narrow the relief or write formal rules. Crypto and brokerage firms building tokenized-equity businesses face the prospect of added compliance costs, including wallet screening and transfer restrictions, if the agency concedes the gaps.

The political backdrop adds pressure. The four senators were involved in negotiating the CLARITY Act, the crypto market-structure bill that stalled in the Senate, and Democrats are positioned to gain committee oversight relevant to crypto policy after the midterms, setting up continued scrutiny of the SEC's tokenization agenda into next year.

Separately, crypto exchange Backpack said Monday it had secured Commodity Futures Trading Commission approval to establish a U.S. derivatives exchange and clearinghouse built on blockchain infrastructure, clearing the way for leveraged crypto perpetual futures trading. CFTC Chair Michael Selig said blockchain-based operators must meet the same standards as traditional firms, including AML, customer protection and market surveillance requirements. Backpack also runs a tokenized equities business, though the CFTC approvals concern derivatives rather than the SEC exemption under challenge.

Once added, BigGo Finance appears first in Google Search Top Stories, so you get the broadest, most up-to-the-minute, and most comprehensive global financial news first.

More Related News