Strategy's signature method of expanding its bitcoin holdings — issuing stock that trades at a premium to the value of the bitcoin it holds and using the proceeds to buy more — has stopped working at current prices, according to Peter Schiff, a longtime bitcoin critic who said the company's modified net asset value has fallen below 1.

"The highly touted mNAV of Strategy is now below 1," Schiff wrote on X on Thursday. "Given yesterday's heavy sell volume in $STRC, and its current share price below $96, it looks like the entire $MSTR ecosystem is about to blow up." He described the company as possibly "the pin that pricks not just the Bitcoin bubble, but all of crypto."

The metric matters because Strategy (MSTR) can only increase bitcoin per share by selling equity when that equity trades above the value of the bitcoin backing it. Below 1, each new share brings in less cash than the bitcoin it represents, diluting existing holders rather than enriching them. Management set an even higher bar: on its first-quarter earnings call in May, it put the break-even for buying bitcoin with newly issued stock at 1.22x mNAV.

Twelve Weeks of Gains, Financed by Dilution

The warning came hours after Strategy published its own scorecard, saying swaps had increased net bitcoin per share in each of the last 12 weeks. Selling MSTR above its net bitcoin value while repurchasing STRC below $100 added roughly 580 sats per common share before preferred dividends, according to the company.

That gain required substantial share issuance. Strategy's diluted share count nearly doubled between the end of 2024 and the third quarter of 2026. The selling continued into November: in the week through Nov. 15, the company sold $244.7 million of common stock, and Executive Chairman Michael Saylor said it bought back $228 million of STRC.

STRC is Strategy's 12% perpetual preferred stock, designed to trade near $100 with monthly dividend-rate adjustments. It now trades below $96.

The erosion of the premium shows up in the valuation. Bitcoin accounted for 94.5% of Strategy's assets as of June 30, so book value tracks the token. The stock now trades at 0.7x book, the lowest in three years, against a three-year average of 6.1x and a peak of 25.4x in November 2024.

Note: Cash and short-term investments figure as of Sept. 30, 2026; USD asset figure as of Nov. 15, 2026.

Saylor Vows to Keep Buying, but the Funding Mix Shifts

Saylor is not retreating. "We intend to keep buying below $100," he posted on Thursday, adding that buybacks "lower dividend obligations." He has said the company's $4.9 billion in USD assets can fund 3.4 years of interest and dividends at current rates.

Schiff expects a different sequence: Strategy will "blow through its cash reserve to buy more, then start selling Bitcoin to buy what's left." Every STRC repurchase below $100 now draws on that cash cushion unless the company keeps issuing stock and accepts less bitcoin per share. Once cash runs low, bitcoin becomes the funding source.

Strategy held 850,849 bitcoin as of the latest disclosure.

Contagion Risk for MARA and Coinbase

A Strategy forced to sell would not be alone in the market. MARA Holdings (MARA) is already doing what Schiff anticipates: after the third quarter it sold bitcoin to repay $750 million of bitcoin-backed debt, according to its quarterly shareholder letter, and it plans to keep converting bitcoin into cash ahead of next year's convertible-note puts and a new $500 million buyback.

Coinbase (COIN) depends on crypto trading for revenue, and its third-quarter transaction revenue was already down 44% from a year earlier. Analysts expect a normalized loss of $0.32 a share for 2026, followed by $2.46 of earnings in 2027 — a rebound that requires trading activity to recover. Selling by the largest corporate bitcoin holder would work against that.

Schiff has predicted bitcoin's collapse for most of the past 13 years, and his call on Strategy is more aggressive than the balance sheet supports: the company holds billions in cash and is under no obligation to repurchase a single STRC share. But the arithmetic of the trade is not in dispute. Until MSTR trades above the value of its bitcoin again, the company functions as a leveraged bitcoin holder spending down its cash reserve. Bitcoin's price can close the gap quickly, and an mNAV back above 1 would put the swap back on the table.

Once added, BigGo Finance appears first in Google Search Top Stories, so you get the broadest, most up-to-the-minute, and most comprehensive global financial news first.

More Related News