Published on

by

A pair of computer programmers accused of exploiting a software bug to steal millions of dollars in just 12 seconds have been acquitted of wire fraud charges.

The US has failed in its efforts to convince a district court that two brothers who allegedly stole $25 million in cryptocurrency by exploiting the Ethereum blockchain are guilty of wire fraud and money laundering.

Handing down its decision on Monday (16 November), the US District Court for the Southern District of New York acquitted Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno on three charges, holding that the government had failed to prove that the pair had made any material misrepresentations upon which a finding of wire fraud – and consequently, money laundering – rested.

US District Judge Jessica Clarke made clear that the case did not centre on whether the brothers’ conduct was “improper, objectionable or even despicable”. The issue at hand was solely whether the pair had committed wire fraud.

The contested scheme

The Peraire-Bueno brothers were charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering in May 2024 over their involvement in an alleged scheme to fraudulently obtain approximately $25 million in a matter of seconds from cryptocurrency traders. The exploit was said to be the very first of its kind.

According to the government, the Peraire-Buenos’ ‘Omakase’ scheme targeted sandwich traders – who profit off the manipulated inflation of a token’s value – on the blockchain platform Ethereum. Through ‘lure transactions’, the brothers are said to have enticed traders’ bots to trade away millions of dollars in cryptocurrency that would usually be made back, with a small profit. However, the Peraire-Buenos allegedly exploited a coding vulnerability that allowed them to view private transactions and propose their own replacement transactions that disrupted the traders’ strategy. The sandwich traders lost millions in seconds, the government said, while the Peraire-Buenos reaped “significant profits”.

A mistrial was declared in November 2025 after the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict. Before the district court was a motion for acquittal or, alternatively, dismissal of the superseding indictment.

Before the district court

A finding that an individual violated the wire fraud statute requires proof that they devised, or else intended to devise, a scheme to obtain money or property “by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations or promises”. Proving the existence of a scheme to defraud requires the government to prove that the “misrepresentations were material and that the defendant acted with fraudulent intent”.

Judge Clarke said that the evidence at trial “could arguably show that the Peraire-Buenos concocted a scheme to obtain cryptocurrency from sandwich traders on Ethereum”. Yet the government ultimately failed to propose a theory that would lead a reasonable juror to infer that the brothers had conveyed a material misrepresentation through the scheme.

The judge held that none of the three key features of Omakase – the lure transactions, the submission of a false digital signature and the failure to act in accordance with the software’s specifications – could be considered a material representation by the Peraire-Buenos. She also rejected the “government’s repeat attempts to rid the court of its obligation find a material misrepresentation”.

The superseding indictment had charged the Peraire-Buenos with conspiracy to launder the proceeds of wire fraud, meaning the money laundering charge fell with the wire fraud. Judge Clarke concluded that “no reasonable juror applying the law could find the Peraire-Buenos guilty of conspiracy to commit money laundering”, emphasising that the jury had been instructed to find that the financial transactions involved wire fraud proceeds.

Finding that the government had failed to prove material misrepresentations by the Peraire-Buenos, the court acquitted the pair.

Related publications

Related jurisdictions

Tagged with:

Latest News