Key Facts

  • Most third-quarter buying of US spot Bitcoin ETFs came in near $80,070, leaving those investors about 20% below cost with Bitcoin near $63,500, Bitfinex analysts estimate.

  • Wells Fargo's IBIT stake doubled to 49.6 million shares in the third quarter, and outflows since Oct. 30 equal about half of the quarter's $6.36 billion of inflows.

  • Bitfinex expects ETF demand to lag price for several weeks and wants three straight sessions of inflows before it reads a change in sentiment.

Most third-quarter buying of US spot Bitcoin ETFs came in near $80,070, leaving those investors about 20% below cost with Bitcoin near $63,500, Bitfinex analysts estimate.

Wells Fargo's IBIT stake doubled to 49.6 million shares in the third quarter, and outflows since Oct. 30 equal about half of the quarter's $6.36 billion of inflows.

Bitfinex expects ETF demand to lag price for several weeks and wants three straight sessions of inflows before it reads a change in sentiment.

Bitfinex analysts named the buyers in a note on Wednesday.

Take a walk down memory lane with CMC Wrapped, as we revisit the nearly 14 years of crypto history since CoinMarketCap first launched, starting with 2013-2016. Click here to learn how it all began.

Where Did ETF Buyers Get In? Near $80,000

Bitcoin traded at $63,471 at 9:57 a.m. ET on Wednesday, CoinMarketCap data show.

Most of the buying arrived between Aug. 17 and Sept. 25, near the top of the rally. Weighted by each day's flows, those buyers paid about $80,070, by Bitfinex's estimate.

The wider holder base is also under water. Bitcoin sits about a quarter below the average cost of all ETF holdings since launch, according to Checkonchain data cited by Bitfinex.

Who Bought the Rally? Bank Clients and Hedge Funds

Most of those shares sit at its brokerage arms. Galaxy head of firmwide research Alex Thorn wrote that this makes them "client positions not prop bank or trading business holdings."

Hedge funds Brevan Howard and Millennium built up their stakes, Bitfinex noted.

The filings list the long positions each manager held on Sept. 30. Selling after that date shows up only in daily flows.

How Much Has Left Since? About Half, by Bitfinex Count

The funds have lost about $3.2 billion since Oct. 30, with outflows on most days, Farside Investors data show.

That equals about half of their inflows from July through September, by Bitfinex's count.

Monday's small inflow was a pause rather than a return of demand, Bitfinex analysts wrote.

What Would Turn Flows? Three Straight Days of Inflows

Bitfinex wants three straight sessions of inflows, comparable in size to the outflows before them. That, with steadier CME positions, would bring $72,700 into view.

Acceptance below $61,300 with daily outflows above $300 million would point to the $57,803 cycle low, the firm wrote.

The May-to-July decline offers a guide. ETF holdings bottomed after Bitcoin's July 1 low and did not recover until mid-August, Bitfinex noted.

"We would therefore expect ETF demand to lag price again, leaving a potential price bottom unconfirmed by flows for several weeks," the firm wrote.

The funds have taken in money on just two days since Oct. 30.