THIS COLUMN HAS PREVIOUSLY discussed cryptocurrencies and property (see China Business Law Journal, volume 17, issue 5: Cryptocurrencies and property. It noted that the emergence of cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin, has presented challenges regarding the applicability of traditional legal doctrines and rules.
On the one hand, cryptocurrencies can be dealt with in the same way as other assets. They can be held directly by an owner, and they can also be held by intermediaries such as crypto cryptocurrency exchanges.
On the other hand, many cryptocurrencies present unique issues that do not apply to other intangible assets such as shares or other securities. For example, there is often no issuer, and it is often difficult to identify a cryptocurrency’s location. Additionally, difficulties arise when determining ownership because of the pseudonymity of the “owner”.
Therefore, the proprietary nature of cryptocurrencies is still uncertain in many jurisdictions. As noted in the previous column, some courts in China have decided that cryptocurrencies possess attributes of “virtual assets” because they satisfy various criteria, including having economic value and being capable of possession, and have granted proprietary remedies (such as restitution) for cryptocurrencies.
In insolvency proceedings, the concept of property is of fundamental importance as it determines what assets are available to repay creditors of an insolvent company or bankrupt person and the nature of the rights that exist concerning assets, including any rights that secured creditors enjoy (for a discussion of the difference between insolvency and bankruptcy, see China Business Law Journal, volume 4, issue 10: Bankrupt or insolvent.
This column discusses some of the challenges that cryptocurrencies present in the context of insolvency.
These challenges include the application of conflict of laws principles, such as determining the law of the place where digital assets are situated (lex situs); whether creditors can initiate insolvency proceedings based on claims concerning cryptocurrencies; and the relief available in insolvency proceedings.
It concludes with some comments about the law in the Chinese mainland.
If cryptocurrencies are property, where are they considered to be located for the purpose of determining choice of law (lex situs) and jurisdiction? The question of where an asset is located is relevant to determining which jurisdiction’s laws apply to, and which courts have jurisdiction over, issues such as the enforcement of rights in respect of the asset and the transfer of the asset from one party to another party.
In the case of land, for example, the rules of private international law in most jurisdictions provide that the applicable law is the law of the place in which the land is situated – the lex situs (or “law of the site”) – and that the courts in that place have jurisdiction to determine ownership and other matters relating to the land. In the case of tangible property, the rules generally provide that the applicable law is the law of the jurisdiction where the property is physically located at the relevant time.
In the case of a debt, the rules generally provide that the applicable law is the law of the jurisdiction where the debtor resides or carries on business.
This is based on the principle that the location of intangible property, such as a chose in action, should be determined by reference to where it is possible to take action and enforce the associated rights.
The question of where cryptocurrencies are located is complicated by two realities. The first reality is that they have no physical form and are “borderless” in nature, given that they are often recorded and maintained on decentralised (globally distributed) public ledgers and cannot be identified with any one jurisdiction.
The second reality is that there is often no “issuer” as in the case of shares, where the lex situs is generally considered to be the location of the company’s share register. Therefore, jurisdictions have struggled to date to come to terms with the question of applicable law for cryptocurrencies.
In its Principles on Digital Assets and Private Law (2023), the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT) has proposed a “waterfall” of factors for a forum to consider in determining applicable law (principle 5). To resolve uncertainty, UNIDROIT suggests that those who create digital assets should specify the applicable law in the digital asset itself or the relevant system.
To date, some jurisdictions (such as the UK) have determined the location of a digital asset based on the domicile or habitual residence of the person or company that owns the digital asset.
Do cryptocurrencies constitute ‘debt’ for the purposes of a statutory demand? Many jurisdictions allow the initiation of insolvency proceedings by a creditor where an entity is unable to pay its debts. In Australia, for example, a creditor of a company can make an application to the court for orders winding up the company where the company has failed to comply with a statutory demand and is presumed to be insolvent.
A statutory demand is a creditor’s formal, written request requiring a company to pay a debt within the statutory period. The demand must be in writing and must relate to a debt or debts that are due and payable and total at least AUD4,000 (USD2,785). If a company fails to comply with a statutory demand within the statutory period, the company is presumed to be insolvent.
Within three months of the date of non-compliance, the creditor who served the demand may rely on the presumption of insolvency as the basis for an application to the court for orders winding up the company.
The statutory demand process is also available in the UK, where it has been noted that although digital assets fall within the definition of “property” in the Insolvency Act 1986 for various purposes, a statutory demand cannot yet be served in respect of a digital asset on the basis that digital assets are not yet treated as money.
The same issue arises in relation to statutory demands in Australia, where a statutory demand can only be issued for a “debt” and, to date, courts have held that the ordinary meaning of the word “debt” refers to “a sum of money that is now payable or will become payable in future by reason of a present obligation”.
However, the possibility remains that cryptocurrencies may come to be recognised as “money” at some point in the future and that a claim for the payment of an amount in cryptocurrencies will support a statutory demand.
What challenges do cryptocurrencies present in relation to insolvency proceedings and the relief available in insolvency proceedings? Experience to date in many jurisdictions suggests that the existing legal framework in common law jurisdictions has generally been able to accommodate disputes involving cryptocurrencies in terms of the relief available and the orders granted in insolvency proceedings.
In the UK, for example, the UK Jurisdiction Taskforce has stated the following:
- Existing English insolvency law is entirely capable of convenient and sensible application to disputes concerning digital assets. Although the issues which arise are technical and fact-specific in nature, they can be resolved by recourse to existing and well-established principles.”
- “The interlocutory, investigatory and enforcement powers generally available to insolvency office-holders under English law are available in relation to digital assets. Office-holders may require a wide range of people, such as officers and former officers of a company and certain employees, to provide information and documents, and they may apply to a judge for an order that relevant private keys be disclosed.”
- “Our view is that English insolvency law as it presently stands is entirely capable of convenient and sensible application to disputes concerning digital assets.”
That said, four challenges can be identified because of the unique characteristics of cryptocurrencies.
First, the pseudonymous nature of the “owner” of cryptocurrencies means that it is often difficult, if not impossible, to determine the identity, or the physical location, of the owner or the person who has control over the private key and can get access to the wallet in which the private key is held.
Therefore, some jurisdictions have allowed service of proceedings on “persons unknown” through various means, including the UK and Singapore.
Second, information about cryptocurrencies is difficult to obtain, and there is very little information that is immediately available, apart from the publicly available data (such as the public key) identifying cryptocurrencies on the blockchain.
Disclosure orders against parties have become increasingly important and have been granted by courts in various jurisdictions.
Because of the difficulties in relation to cryptocurrencies, it is often necessary to engage digital forensic experts to assist in obtaining information about cryptocurrencies and in their recovery.
Third, the speed and ease with which cryptocurrencies can be transferred mean that freezing orders are an important form of interlocutory relief.
Finally, valuation issues are relevant to how much the value of cryptocurrencies can fluctuate. As the UK Jurisdiction Taskforce has noted, “the volatile nature of digital assets might present particular challenges regarding the fair realisation of value”.
Given these realities, insolvency practitioners often obtain approvals or orders for the immediate liquidation of cryptocurrencies to avoid the risk of losing value.
The Chinese mainland
As noted in the previous column, article 115 of the Civil Code provides that the concept of “property” includes immovable property and movable property. In addition, article 127 of the Civil Code provides that “where the law provides for the protection of data and virtual property on the internet, such provisions shall apply”.
Accordingly, there is a basis for the recognition of cryptocurrencies as “property” or “virtual property” and for cryptocurrencies to be considered part of the estate of a company under China’s Enterprise Bankruptcy Law. To date, however, there are no specific provisions that govern the treatment of cryptocurrencies in the context of insolvency.
Because of the current prohibitions on trading cryptocurrencies, insolvency administrators face practical challenges when they take control of cryptocurrencies and try to sell them during the liquidation process.
The prohibitions on the trading of cryptocurrencies have prevented the development of a liquid market in such assets. Over time, law and practice will likely need to evolve to accommodate and support the treatment of digital assets in insolvency.
This column is based on a detailed paper, versions of which were delivered by the author at the Restructuring and Insolvency Academic Forum 2026 (hosted by the National University of Singapore and the Thammasat University in Bangkok on 18 and 19 June 2026), the Banking and Financial Services Law Association Symposium in the Gold Coast, Australia, on 20 August 2026; and the Supreme Court of Victoria Commercial Law Conference on Friday on 26 August 2026.
Andrew Godwin previously practised as a foreign lawyer in Shanghai (1996-2006) before returning to his alma mater, Melbourne Law School in Australia, to teach and research law. Andrew is currently Joint Associate Director of the Corporate Law and Financial Regulation Research Programme at the Melbourne Centre for Commercial Law and Honorary Associate Director (Commercial law) of the Asian Law Centre. Andrew has acted as a consultant to a broad range of organisations, regulators and governments in Australia and abroad. He served as Special Counsel and Acting General Counsel of the Australian Law Reform Commission between 2020 and 2024.


